Many of the health sayings we still repeat today did not come from science. They emerged from humoral theory, early physiology guesses, cultural symbolism, and trial-and-error medicine that often mistook confidence for correctness. What survived wasn’t the mechanism or the evidence. It was the rhyme, the metaphor, the phrase that sounded right. Over time, these sayings detached from their origins, leaving behind advice that feels familiar but is often biologically meaningless or outright wrong.
Practices like tobacco-smoke enemas, snake oil cures, bloodletting, and symbolic treatments such as “a hair of the dog” all share the same flaw: stimulation or short-term relief was confused with healing. Early medicine lacked an understanding of physiology, immunity, and inflammation, so visible reactions were taken as proof of effectiveness. Loud claims replaced evidence, persuasion replaced mechanism, and suffering was often moralised as part of treatment rather than questioned.
Modern science paints a very different picture. Health outcomes depend on dose, mechanism, and reproducibility. Immune responses require energy, not starvation. Inflammation is a regulated biological process, not excess heat to be suppressed through deprivation. Nutrients only matter if they are absorbed, and symptom relief does not equal recovery. Even sayings that partially hold true, like “an apple a day,” do so not because of magic, but because they loosely align with broader dietary patterns that support gut and metabolic health.
The pattern across centuries is remarkably consistent. Symptoms were treated as causes. Short-term effects were mistaken for solutions. Confidence was rewarded over accuracy. Science has not eliminated uncertainty, but it has replaced folklore with physiology and belief with mechanism. The sayings survived because they were memorable. The science moved on because it worked. And that, perhaps, is the most important health lesson we keep forgetting.
We are so grateful for your support, so we’d like to offer you a special Renovatio deal:
PS: This session was recorded LIVE, thank you to everyone who tuned in!
Thank you to everyone who tuned into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.
